Supreme Court Lets Stand Texas Ruling That Could Undermine Marriage Equality

05 December, 2017, 02:39 | Author: Diane Mills
  • The US Supreme Court Just Rejected a Texas Case About Gay Marriage Rights

Our country's highest court has let stand a ruling by the Texas Supreme Court that says gay couples are not entitled to the same spousal employee insurance benefits as heterosexual couples.

The case that goes before the U.S. Supreme Court for oral arguments on December 5 is a showdown between a gay couple from Colorado and a Denver-area baker who in 2012 cited his Christian faith in refusing to make a cake for their wedding celebration.

"What an incredible early Christmas present from the U. S. Supreme Court", said Saenz, president of Texas Values, according to the American-Statesman. "Today's abnegation by the nation's highest court opens the door for an onslaught of challenges to the rights of LGBTQ people at every step". The city of Houston appealed the decision to the Supreme Court, arguing that it violated the precedent established by Obergefell. Houston has continued to provide benefits to all of its married employees through-out the pending litigation.

In June, the Texas Supreme Court threw out the ruling favoring Houston, agreeing that the Obergefell decision "did not hold that states must provide the same publicly funded benefits to all married persons", and remanded the case back to the trial court to allow the men to make their arguments again.

Jim Griffin, a Dallas lawyer who advises businesses on employee benefits plans, surmised that Houston's appeal was rejected because the Supreme Court did not have a final decision on marriage benefits to examine.

More news: Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Attend First Official Royal Engagement Together

The ruling returned the lawsuit to a Houston district court to determine whether the U.S. Supreme Court's marriage ruling applies to spousal benefits provided by Houston.

The case of Masterpiece Cakeshop versus Colorado Civil Rights Commission began five years ago when Charlie Craig and Dave Mullins asked Phillips to make a cake for their wedding reception.

That does not mean Houston can "constitutionally deny benefits to its employees' same-sex spouses", the court added, but the issue must now be resolved "in light of Obergefell". "We're grateful that the U.S. Supreme Court has allowed our lawsuit to go forward", Saenz said.

The high court ruled that states must give same-sex couples the same rights as opposite-sex couples or else the state would be giving same-sex couples "disparate treatment", something forbidden under Obergefell.

Recommended:

  • CFP semifinal features Georgia and Oklahoma in Rose Bowl

    CFP semifinal features Georgia and Oklahoma in Rose Bowl

    While the top three spots are clear, the No. 4 spot is where the committee's work begins on Saturday night and Sunday morning. Because of this, whichever school "wins" the Alabama/Ohio State debate will nearly undoubtedly be the No. 4 seed.
    Aaron Boone Walks into Perfect Job as Next New York Yankees Manager

    Aaron Boone Walks into Perfect Job as Next New York Yankees Manager

    His father, Bob, was a four-time All-Star catcher from 1972-90, then managed Kansas City from 1995-97 and Cincinnati from 2001-03. Girardi was let go on October 26 after a decade at the helm following the team's narrow failure to advance to the World Series.
    Senate tax plan will not pay for itself, says new JCT report

    Senate tax plan will not pay for itself, says new JCT report

    A GOP summary obtained by The Associated Press showed that to pay for the changes, the new plan would scale back several tax cuts. GOP leaders' main concern was winning over the hawks anxious about adding more red ink to the mounting $20 trillion deficit.
  • Natrez Patrick arrested again according to jail report

    Natrez Patrick arrested again according to jail report

    Patrick is Georgia's sixth-leading tackler with 35 stops, and he had three tackles in the SEC championship game . Patrick was recently arrested for possession of marijuana in Athens-Clarke County in October .
    Russian FM: Haley's North Korea statement 'bloodthirsty'

    Russian FM: Haley's North Korea statement 'bloodthirsty'

    Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov slammed on Friday US Ambassador to the UN Nikki Haley's recent remarks regarding North Korea.
    Jimbo Fisher Reportedly Named Texas A&M HC After 8 Years at FSU

    Jimbo Fisher Reportedly Named Texas A&M HC After 8 Years at FSU

    Fisher was 83-23 in his eight seasons in Tallahassee, including one national title that he won with Jameis Winston in 2013. The safety committed to Texas A&M in June, picking the program over LSU, Nebraska, Clemson , Oklahoma, Georgia and Texas.
  • Facebook Launches New Messenger Kids App

    Facebook Launches New Messenger Kids App

    Sounds entertaining... enough, but also safe and practical for parents constantly anxious with the perils of the open web. The application is available for preview in the USA and will roll out to iPhone, iPad, and iPod touch initially.
    Time's Person of the Year Finalists

    Time's Person of the Year Finalists

    Dreamers , undocumented youth who were brought to America illegally by their parents when they were infants and children. TIME's first selection was Charles Lindbergh, the first person to make a solo non-stop flight across the Atlantic .
    Supermoon 2017: This weekend's moon is the biggest of the year

    Supermoon 2017: This weekend's moon is the biggest of the year

    However, in my new house, the moon does not seem anywhere near as big or bright even though it's the exact same moon. When the moon is closest, the tide will be at its highest, and the same happens with a new or full moon.
  • Afghan soil used in Peshawar university attack

    Afghan soil used in Peshawar university attack

    It is also expected that the militant group would also release detailed footage of the attack, received through the streaming. The area where the incident occurred is a hub for educational institutions in the city including the university of Peshawar .
    LeClerc and Ericsson earn Sauber seats

    LeClerc and Ericsson earn Sauber seats

    Sauber has unveiled its concept livery for the 2018 Formula 1 season, in the wake of its collaboration with FCA brand Alfa Romeo. Leclerc is a current member of the Ferrari Driver Academy, and he is widely considered one of the future stars of Formula One .
    Super moon to be seen on Sunday night

    Super moon to be seen on Sunday night

    Though this will be the fourth supermoon of 2017, the previous three were not visible because they coincided with new moons. If you want to celebrate the year's most super supermoon as a holiday for moongazers, I don't see anything wrong with that.


Popular

Former President Barack Obama Thinks We Need More Women In Power
Trump has threatened several times to withdraw from the Paris accord saying it is crippling USA business. Obama then spoke on the mindfulness that should be exercised when using Twitter and all social media .

Rickie Fowler finishes in style but Tiger Woods' challenge fades
Following a flawless front-nine 31, Woods stumbled with a sloppy double-bogey on the 10th hole. He added three more birdies on the back nine for a sizzling, bogey-free round.

NCAA issues punishment on Ole Miss
A show-cause on an NCAA coach means the coach does not escape the penalties by leaving the school where the penalties took place. Ole Miss had self-imposed both a bowl ban for this season and scholarship restrictions, but the NCAA added more to each element.

'Avenger: Infinity War' to release in India before America'
In this film, the Avengers join forces with the Guardians of the Galaxy to confront Thanos, who is trying to collect the Infinity Stones.

Max Hospital to Be Investigated for Declaring a Living Baby as Dead
Now, Parveen and several of his relatives sit outside Max Healthcare in Shalimar Bagh , demanding action against the hospital. Parents in India were told that both of their twins, born prematurely, had died in childbirth.

England get lucky but Gareth Southgate urges caution
Their first fixture is against Tunisia on June 18, with Panama next and the mighty Belgians 10 days after the opener. That will be followed by a meeting with Panama in Nizhni Novgorod, 400 kilometres east of Moscow , on June 24.

Former US NSA employee pleads guilty to taking classified documents
The man, Nghia Hoang Pho, 67, of Ellicott City, Maryland, pleaded guilty today, according to court documents released by the DOJ. A former employee of an elite government hacking group pleaded guilty to illegally taking classified documents .

Arsenal v Manchester United
He said: "I would always try to play the best possible team, even if the Champions League match was a must-win". It's just the game, it's Arsenal, we don't think about how many points behind - just Arsenal.

Victoria's Secret Models Under Fire For Rapping N-Word
Unfortunately, some of the ladies were comfortable saying the n-word. "Black people can use it as freely as they want". Social media users have pointed out that there are no black people in the room, so the word should not have been used.

Feds want to seize Martin Shkreli's Wu-Tang album
A Brooklyn jury deliberated five days before finding Shkreli guilty on Friday on three of eight counts. "Our position is clear. Shkreli was convicted in August of misleading investors in two of his hedge funds, MSMB Capital and MSMB Healthcare.